A patentable invention must be new, inventive, capable of industrial application and must not fall into an excluded category (e.g. artistic creations, mathematical methods, some computer programs, and business schemes). PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys will help with determining the question of patentability.
Establishing whether an invention meets these criteria is a complicated, time consuming and expensive process. Although patenting is expensive (e.g. $ 100,000 over five years), the rewards may be significant. If inventions are not properly protected, rights may be lost irretrievably.
1. THINK PATENT BEFORE YOU PUBLISH
The opportunity for obtaining a patent can be lost by publication of the underlying research. No information on an invention should be made available to the public in any way anywhere in the world prior to a patent application being filed. This includes publication in grant applications, journals either as articles or as letters, oral presentation at seminars, or information posted on notice boards on the Internet, abstracts, theses, e-mails, poster displays, exhibitions, open days, or confidential disclosures to many people. Any “enabling” information about an invention which is published in any way will constitute a disclosure and weaken or destroy its patentability. An enabling disclosure is one which provides the means by which someone skilled in the subject could reproduce the work about to be patented.
Patent provisions in the USA are different (they operate a first to invent system, rather than the first to file system), and if the invention has been disclosed, PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys will advise as to whether it is still possible for valid patent protection to be secured in the USA.
PAPPAS IP will not prevent you from publishing your work. A patent application can be prepared and filed quite quickly (days, more normally weeks) once a patent attorney has been instructed. As soon as the patent application has been filed there is no restriction on subsequent publication of the invention, subject to the points below.
Following filing an initial patent application no information which is new or additional should be published without first checking with the patent attorney involved in the case. It is possible that the new information could be included in the patent application. If the information needs to be included in the patent application the only way this can be done is by way of a new updated application; and the same requirement for novelty as discussed above will apply in so far as the new application is concerned.
If there is a risk that necessary development work or securing necessary investment may take more than one year from the filing of the patent application, the invention should not be published or otherwise made available to the public during that year. Any new patent applications filed in the UK within a year of the filing date of an original patent application for the same invention are entitled to claim the filing date of the original application. After the first year it is no longer possible to claim priority, and any publication of the invention during that year could be used to challenge the validity of any subsequent application filed outside of the first year. This is important in case it becomes necessary for the original application to be abandoned in favour of a new application with a new filing date.
2. PREPARING THE PATENT APPLICATION
In completing the Invention Record you will be providing to PAPPAS IP important information to help the patent attorney draft the application.
In preparing a patent application the attorney is required to draft a specification which describes the invention in detail and highlights those features of the invention which are new and inventive over what is already known. At least one way for the invention to be put into effect should be included in the specification. Hence information on experimental examples and/or prototypes, although not essential, may make the difference in successfully securing valid patent protection.
The patent application will aim to describe the work in as broad a way as possible, so as to avoid others easily ‘inventing around’ your work. You will be encouraged to speculate as to the possible uses of your work to a level beyond that in an academic publication. The application itself will be published 18 months after filing.
It is possible to describe more than one related invention in a single patent application. In due course, however, the inventions will need to be divided out into separate applications, as a patent is only granted on a single invention. PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys are able to advise.
It is essential to identify accurately the people who made the invention(s) described in the patent application. Inventorship is a matter of fact, not opinion. It is unusual for an invention to be made by more than two or three people. Whilst those associated with research may be included as authors on academic publications, only true inventors may be included on patent applications.
If inventorship is recorded wrongly, this may be enough for the patent authorities to refuse grant of or revoke a patent. PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys are able to assist in discussions to establish correct inventorship.
Patent applications and granted patents are published by patent offices around the world and are publicly available documents. Published patents provide a wealth of information which researchers may wish to access for a number of reasons:
- Assessing the likelihood of your own work being patentable over the existing publications;
- Exploring the way patents are written to clarify the scope of an invention;
- Part of a ‘literature search’ when embarking on a research programme;
- Assessing the likelihood of planned commercial activities infringing existing patents.
- In the majority of countries patent applications are published 18 months after they are filed. US patents are not published
- Until grant -which may be many (2 to 15) years after filing. The published patent information can be accessed free on a number of www sites:
United States Patent & Trademark Office
UK Intellectual Property Office
European Patent Office
Japanese Patent Office
World Intellectual Property Organisation
Australian Patent Office
Canadian Patent Office
PAPPAS IP is able to assist in patent searching.
5. KEEPING A LABORATORY NOTEBOOK
It is only in 1996 that it became possible to prove a date of invention for US Patent purposes from evidence produced outside the US. In order to take advantage of this change in US Patent law inventors must follow certain guidelines. Under US Patent law, an inventor must provide evidence of the following in order to prove a date of invention: date of conception of the invention; reduction to practice of the invention; diligence in achieving reduction to practice.
The evidence which an inventor requires may be in a variety of forms but is frequently contained in a laboratory notebook. In order to provide irrefutable evidence the following procedures are required in keeping a laboratory notebook: Permanent binding (not loose-leaf or spiral bound); Numbered pages; Good paper quality; Permanent ink (not pencil); Legible and factually complete entries; Describe all experimental procedures, giving conditions of experiment and apparatus; Ensure each page is signed off and dated by the author and witnessed as soon as possible (the witness should be someone who understands the area of research but who is not directly involved and cannot be considered to be under the control of the author); Do not leave any gaps, pages unsigned or unwitnessed.
PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys are able to advise on this is issue.
6. PATENT APPLICATION PROCEDURE
Most PAPPAS IP patent applications are filed first in the USA, which establishes an international ‘priority date’; then after 12 months international protection is sought via the Patent Co-operation Treaty (PCT). This enables filing of a single patent application to establish protection in a range of countries. It simplifies international patent filing and prosecution, and defers costs. Over one hundred countries have signed the PCT, and these can all be designated in one patent application. In addition PAPPAS IP may file a separate regional patent application to protect better this important market.
The maximum life of a patent in most countries of the world is 20 years from the initial filing date. Further protection can sometimes be achieved for some products in some markets (e.g. Supplementary Protection Certificates).
Start Patent Application filed in UK; Priority Date established; Further exemplification of the invention must be done within the next 12 months, this period being crucial for adding value to the patent.
THE OPPORTUNITY FOR OBTAINING A PATENT CAN BE LOST BY PUBLICATION BEFORE FILING.
- 1st year Updated Application filed; At this stage more data can be added to the invention; Overseas countries are designated under the PCT system
- 1.5 years Patent Application published with search report.
- 2 – 4 years Patent Examiner report received, the patent attorney working with the PAPPAS IP Project Manager, inventor(s) and the examiner to negotiate and agree the Patent claims
- 5 – 7 years Patent granted / refused in each of the designated countries
- 4 – 20 years Annual renewal fees payable
PAPPAS IP and its patent attorneys are able to assist and advise on all aspects of patenting.